2023: Stella Blake
2022: Kayla Martin
2021: Torrie Forrest
2020: Covid
2019: Allison Waggoner
2018: Dynasty Ford
2017: Mallory McCreedy
2016: Taylor Penird Baxter
2015: Brittany Ring
2014: Kelby Smith Davis
2013: Samantha Hudzik
2012: Brittany Hines
2011: Chelsea Foster
2010: Alexandria Bryant
2009: Lauren Shanower Jackson
2008: Katie Poole
2007: Christina Hagan Nemeth
2006: Kayla Faudree Heimann
2005: Erica Burmeister Speelman
2004: Lana Schuette Stillwell
2003: Colbee Carbone
2002: Nanette Gleich
2001: Amanda Brown
2000: Dr. Maryam Jadhi
1999: Erica Kirksey Jackson
1998: Nicole Edwards Brown
1997: Jennifer Smith Bilcze
1996: Tenille Billheimer
1995: Kathie Haywood-Miranda
1994: Jennifer Sturgess Yoder
1993: Vanessa Niner Heim
1992: Joanna White Waite
1991: Debora Valentine Weekly
1990: Onnaliesa Chaney Wright
1989: Melissa Bowlin Geraldo
1988: Angela Goegan Janos
1987: Angie Walker Gary
1986: Lisa Zavarelli Willis
1985: Laura Britton
1984: Kristi Wilson Daily
1983: Dawn Marie Boyce (Deceased)
1982: Angela Connor Curtis
1981: Beth Ann Antonosani
1980: Michelle Zamagias Valentine
1979: Jill North Lancia
1978: Patty Frasher Harper
1977: Terry Kent
1976: Mary Ann Grove McAllister
1975: Cindy Sacco Shetler (Deceased)
1974: Stephanie Samay Katusin
1973: Dena Thomas (Deceased)
1972: Sharon Oswalt Kowaleski
1971: Susan Aebi Feller
1970: Vicki Barret Herbert (Deceased)
1969: Cathy Bunch Brogan
1968: Diane Kulieke Feller (Deceased)
1967: Patty Slusser Kaintz
1966: Jean McClintock Enzian
1965: Becky Burden Tiegler
1964: Sandy Allen Tosha
1963: Judy Kell Swearingen
1962: Nancy Hunt Kile
1961: Jenny Betz Young
1960: Patricia Novelino Dobransky (Deceased)

​​*In 2020 the Greater Alliance Carnation Festival was cancelled due to the global Coronavirus pandemic and social-distancing guidelines.